‘What is language?’

Student notes for Part 2 This question asks something seemingly simple: ‘What is language?’ The question however is more complicated than it first appears, because it requires you to critically evaluate two very different ways in which this question has been addressed: the way of experimental psychology and the way of discursive psychology. You need, in other words, to be able to take two quite different perspectives on language and to convey both perspectives to the reader of your essay. You are also being asked to give examples used by cognitive, developmental and social psychologists, so you will need to refer to at least one study from each of these domains within your essay. Note however that it is not necessary nor expected that you include an example from both perspectives (experimental and discursive) for each of the psychological domains (cognitive, developmental and social). With respect to experimental psychology, you have encountered some examples of how language has been explored from this perspective in Week 5 of the module (for example, in the AV material in the Week 5 Study Guide, and the corresponding textbook chapter, Chapter 4). The second perspective, that of discursive psychology, was introduced in Weeks 12 and 13 (Chapters 9 and 10). You are asked to critically evaluate the differences at play in these two ways of addressing the question ‘What is language?’ Doing this is partly a matter of evaluating the strengths and weaknesses of both approaches, but in so doing you should make clear the important differences between them, both theoretically (how they think about the nature of language) and practically (the methods used in studying it). ‘

The introduction to the Week 5 Study Guide presents itself as continuing ‘your exploration of the use of experimentation, applying it to language’. So here language is very much the topic and experimentation is the means by which we gain knowledge of that topic. For this reason, Chapter 4, Section 2 asks the direct question ‘What is language?’ The answer that is offered sets the scene for the main body of the chapter, which deals with the relationship between language and thought, on the assumption, spelled out on p. 157, that ‘thinking underlies language’. Not all of the methods discussed in this material are experimental, and so you will need to be discerning about which you use, but there are plenty of examples of experimental work discussed. For example, within Chapter 4 you will find discussions of experimental work on the impact of language on colour discrimination (Section 4.1) and time perception (Section 4.2), and in Week 5 you will find AV material discussing how laboratory experiments can be used to understand how babies learn to perceive language. For the discursive psychology part of your answer, you can use either Week 12 (and Chapter 9) or Week 13 (Chapter 10) or, if you prefer, draw material from both. You will not get more marks simply because you draw material from both, so whichever option you choose should be about finding your preferred way of answering. As Alison Davies makes clear in the welcome audio of the introduction to the Week 12 Study Guide, discursive psychology offers an alternative theoretical approach to cognitive psychology.

This includes an alternative method (i.e. discourse analysis), which is quite different from experimentation. She describes discourse analysis as a focus on the performative aspects of language, and this issue is also discussed and illustrated in the textbook chapters. Paul Stenner puts forward a similar point in the welcome audio to Week 13, stating that discursive methodologies study the organisation of talk in daily life, and not the psychological processes assumed to exist beneath the talk. This means that, unlike with Chapter 4, language as such is not the direct topic of Chapters 9 and 10, and this difference is important to the question set. Chapter 9 deals with the topic of identities related to ADHD and Chapter 10 deals with the topic of autobiographical remembering. You will need to understand how and why discursive psychologists approach these topics as ‘topics within discourse’, and hence as part of language. As the question requires you to draw on studies from at least two weeks of the module, you will need to present an overview of both ways of thinking about language and carefully select some illustrative examples to focus on in your essay. As the word limit is only 2000 words, you will need to keep your points directly relevant and to summarise your evaluation effectively. There is no requirement for your answer to come down on one side or other of the two ways of thinking about language, but it is important that you convey a critical sense of the difference between the approaches.

Share This Post


Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

Task 2: Argumentative Research Paper- Organic foods verses GMOs

Writing a research paper gives you an opportunity to explore a topic of special interest, research that topic, and organize your research findings in writing for an academic audience.   Through your preparation work, you have established an argumentative thesis statement and have planned a clear organization of your main

M3A1: Citizens United

http://digital.films.com.vlib.excelsior.edu/p_ViewVideo.aspx?xtid=6976 (copy and paste the link) Review Campaign Finance: Abuses and Reforms. [Video File] [48 min 25 sec] before you participate in this activity. Parts of the video will discuss aspects of campaign finance and reform. Before engaging in this activity, please return to the first discussion topic on political

Analyze how the Republicans and Democrats in the post-war era largely

In a 4-5 page essay, analyze how the Republicans and Democrats in the post-war era largely agreed on Cold War foreign policy but came to different conclusions regarding domestic social policies. How did each party reconcile its foreign and domestic policies, and what does this say about the political ideology

The decision in Williams v Roffey Bros signals that the courts in

The decision in Williams v Roffey Bros signals that the courts in deciding whether or not to enforce a promise, may be guided less by technical questions of consideration than by questions of fairness, reasonableness and commercial utility.   The assignment will be in accordance with the following criteria: •

Management and Organizational Behavior.

Description Exercise 17: Read Annual Pay Raises (W-68-69). This is located in the color-coded workbook section in the back of your book. ( Uhl-Bien, M., Osborn, R. N., & Schermerhorn, J. R. (2014).) Organizational Behavior. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley. ISBN:9781118517376 Review the exercise and complete steps 1 and 2. For this

JP Morganchase Bank

Clearly present brief history, purpose, advertisement, competition, audience and location for that one institution. The information provided is supported with ample applicable data/evidence. analyze historical and current policy of the institution in reference to the Great Recession. use fact finder U.S. Census : Zip code Population Income Education Race PowerPoint:

The Wall of Silence Reflective Journal

 Assignment Instructions: For this course, you will be reading The Wall of Silence by Gibson and Singh (2003). Please read the book and reflect upon what you have read, and complete the assignment as described. The purpose of this reflective assignment is to provide the approach for connecting The Wall

Implementing the Balanced Scorecard in a Not-for-Profit Organization.

 In this assignment you will be introduced to the balanced scorecard concept and will begin to consider how organizations link strategy with the balanced scorecard approach. We will look at the interrelationship of strategy and the balanced scorecard approach in more depth later on in this course. For now, however,

Company Description and SWOT

Non Alcoholic Beverage company!!!! n this assignment, you will conduct a SWOT (Strength, Weakness, Opportunity, and Threat) analysis for the type of beverage you have selected, and for your company overall. As you work on the assignment, consider why you have chosen one type of non-alcoholic beverage over another and

Oral Language chart of phone conversation

Instructions In an APA formatted paper, paste the template found in doc. sharing. Define each of the terms and then watch the video of two children talking on the phone. Rate the language development of one of the two children in the video found at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sL3vqlHabck Use the SOLOM. Using

Motivations of Private-Sector Organizations

 Presidential Policy Directive 8 (PPD-8) is part of the national preparedness goal and provides a description for preparing for the threats in an all-hazards approach that pose the greatest risk to the United States. Community preparedness is a shared responsibility of the whole community. In addition to the public sector

Effective Resource Allocation

 The discussion assignment for this week includes a review of the Key Assignment Outline completed by one of your classmates, as well as a substantial response to at least one other student. Primary Task Response: Your first task is to post your own Key Assignment Outline to the discussion area

US Government

Answer BOTH of the questions below. Test is open book, open note etc. So, show THOUGHT. EXPLAIN your answers. Answers should be THOROUGH at one to two pages in length. 1) Which approach to foreign policy making, realism or idealism, is best suited for the US at this moment in

Ethics Case Study

A student’s analysis of the ethic case must use the following written structural framework, which can be written as a memorandum to the file. Without the bullet points – these indicate required headings for each of the four sections. The following the description heading below to form a memorandum to

The Relativist Ethical Position.

 In your post, address the following: To what extent would you agree with the view that research should rely on a relativist ethical position—rules or duties may vary across different communities and professional groups? What examples could you suggest to support this view? References: – Doing Research in a Business

What is the overall impact in Muslim communities who have been exposed

 Research in the field of addiction studies has important implications for individuals, groups, organizations, the government, and society at large.Develop and hone your empirical question/issue, search the literature, read and analyze the literature, and form conclusions regarding your research question/issue based on the scientific articles. Number of references: Your paper

Poverty in the classroom

A four-unit research paper in APA formatting centered around the effects of poverty in education. The first unit needs to be about the effects poverty has on students in the classroom and needs to be 8-10 pages. Second unit is on the effects of substance abuse on students in the

Causes of America’s War in Vietnam

Description Formatting 12 font or smaller, standard script (e.g. Calibri, New Times Roman), 1.00-1.25 margins maximum, double spaced, clean appearance, etc. Basic organization is simple— don’t make it difficult Title— choose one that reflects your views on the topic to inform and engage your reader from the start, do not